In 2018 a young Spanish singer and songwriter called Rosalia Vila Tobella released a musical album inspired by the sounds of flamenco, which was full of references to what she termed as ‘sacred femininity.’ That album was called El Mal Querer and it was the beginning of Rosalia as we know her, an award-winning, record-busting, genre-crossing new arrival on the music scene both in Spain and internationally. She pitched herself as a woman trapped in a love-obsession from which the protagonist finally manages to save herself and break free. The same idea of love as an obsession, from a different perspective, had been expressed in poetry less than a century earlier by the Spanish poet Federico Garcia Lorca in his Sonnets of Dark Love. In both cases, these two tales are about desiring something wrong and loving what hurts.

Sonnets of dark love: which darkness?

Drafted between 1934 and 1936, the Sonnets of Dark Love have not received a definitive attribuition by Federico Garcìa Lorca. This is because they were written just prior to the death of the author, assassinated by Francoist militias during the Spanish Civil War. It is known, however, that Lorca had referred to those eleven poems with this title.

But be quick! And then, together entwined,
with love-broken mouths and frayed souls
time will find us utterly destroyed.

From Sonnet of the Garland of Roses

First of all, the darkness sung in these sonnets concerns the nights of the two lovers’ dates. Dark is their dimension, while the light of dawn, on the contrary, separates them. The title also alludes to destructive connotations of their relationship. Their love is not a plain one: it is studded with “dagger and kisses”. It gives rise to a wound that is always open in the author. Finally, darkness can allude to the secrecy of homosexual love – and therefore to its illicitness. In fact, when the author’s heirs decided to publish the texts in 1984 after a long delay, they removed the adjective “dark” from the title, as if it was the hard evidence of the homoerotic inspiration of the sonnets.

The Dark Night: the inheritance from Juan De la Cruz

So now fill with words my madness
or let me live in the tranquil
night of my soul, forever in darkness.

From The poet begs his beloved to write to him

In the fourth poem in the series, The poet begs his beloved to write to him, Lorca explicitly quotes a text that influences the entire collection. It is Dark Night of the Soul by San Juan de la Cruz, a sixteenth-century allegorical poem. There, the author gives voice to his soul, which has come close to God at the end of a journey of spiritual negation. This kind of metaphorical darkness the soul lives in is “more courteous than dawn” because it allows meeting the divinity. It is a “blissful night”. In this context, the union of the beloved – God and the soul – takes place. Differently, Lorca’s poems are much more carnal and erotic. While De La Cruz’s path leads to spiritual realization, Lorca’s one ends in perdition, a madness that dark love feeds. But, in both cases, what guides the two poets in their nights is the light that comes from their hearts.